Skip to main content

Day 3: Pseudoscience

Is SETI Science or Pseudoscience?

What is SETI?

SETI stands for Search of Extraterrestrial Intelligence. It is a private search mainly testing different technological methods with the end goal of gathering evidence of extraterrestrial intelligence whether its through microwaves or improving their technology to search farther.

Discussion:

This discussion was a complete mind boggler; I switched sides twice hearing everybody out. I initially believed it to be pseudoscience, then switched to science, then again back to pseudoscience. I believed it to be pseudoscience on my own due to the fact that the broad claim of "aliens might exist" is unfalsifiable. However, I switched once I heard that technology may just be limiting us and our abilities to falsify or prove this claim; I believed that the process of creating and modifying new technology WAS in fact science. 

However, once again I was convinced when another person in class mentioned how testing the actual technology could never be a fair scientific trial. It is impossible to come to conclusions and record observations on the effectiveness of new SETI technology/communication methods due to the fact that the universe is ultimately infinite. In other words, when a new technology/method does not work during a certain period of time, it does not mean that that technology is ineffective due to the fact that the universe is infinite and there could potentially be an infinite observation time. (Ex. "Maybe our microwave technology will work if it travels further!")

How can SETI be more scientific?

I believe that SETI could be more scientific by collecting data and material from space and determining whether or not there is evidence of a life rather than looking for evidence of communication. By collecting data there may be some theories formed that could drive their search, rather than blindly hoping something or someone receives SETI signals. I also believe that their must be more observational methods whether its through developing breakthrough technology to retrieve more data in the form of in depth photos or something on a similar observable level. 

I 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Day 2: Engineering Design Process

KNEX Project: Team members: Katie Hailey Anjani Team Plan and the Engineering Design Process: Our plan was separated into an 8 step process, otherwise known as the Engineering Design Process Step 1: Define the problem       Our goal today was creating a mode of transportation. We could choose what we were transporting and how it would be moved; In our case, we decided to move a penny Anjani had in her pencil bag. Step 2: Research the problem      In this particular scenario we were constrained with a small bag of KNEX pieces. None of us had experience with these parts, so we began to familiarize ourselves with the mechanics of the pieces. Step 3 + 4: Brainstorm     We ultimately decided on a car rather quickly, but we were not completely sure of the ways we could create a car. Through fumbling with the pieces a little bit and researching pictures of KNEX cars other people had made online, we came up with a final plan which leads us to Step 5. Step...
Post a Comment
Read more

Day 10: Ijams Nature Park

  Ijams Nature Park Notes: Indigenous/grounded view: The balance of nature upkeeps the balance of traits and balance of life and death in natural biodiversity.  Class Thoughts: It was interesting to see the impacts of this activity on myself and heartwarming to hear the shared similar feelings the rest of the class had about this activity as well. From observing things we would have never taken the time to watch to being phone free, it was a shared moment of mindfulness and awareness for everyone, and I thoroughly enjoyed it.  It was also enlightening to see how our topics in class connected to everyone's experience of 'observing' our surroundings with human lenses (Inchworm crossing the table, caterpillar climbing to a seemingly unreachable destination). 
Post a Comment
Read more